Clay vs Concrete Roof Tiles: Which One’s Right for Your Roof?

Both clay and concrete tiles offer beautiful, long-lasting protection for your home—but which one should you choose?

We’ve installed both across Columbus, Powell, Dublin, Worthington, and beyond. Here's how we help homeowners weigh the pros and cons of each option.

What’s the Difference Between Clay and Concrete Roof Tiles?

1. Material & Color

• Clay tiles are made from natural clay, kiln-fired, and often left uncoated.

  • Natural color baked in—no fading over time.

  • Typically reddish or earthy tones, though custom colors are available.

• Concrete tiles are made from sand, cement, and water.

  • Color is often added to the surface (slurry-coated or painted), which can fade.

  • Offers more flexibility in texture and design styles.

👉 If long-term color retention matters most to you, clay wins.

2. Durability & Maintenance

• Clay tile has a track record that spans centuries.

  • Withstands UV, freeze-thaw cycles, and corrosive environments.

  • Less likely to show wear.

• Concrete tile is still very durable, but:

  • Slightly more prone to surface erosion over time.

  • Can fade or discolor faster than clay.

Both are non-combustible, Class A fire-rated, and resistant to hail, wind, and water when installed properly.

3. Weight & Installation

• Concrete tile is heavier than clay.

  • May require structural reinforcement if your home wasn’t originally built for it.

• Clay tile is lighter, depending on style.

  • Easier on the roof frame if weight is a concern.

We’ll inspect your attic and framing before making a recommendation.

4. Cost

• Concrete tiles are typically more budget-friendly up front.

• Clay tiles cost more but often retain their value better long-term due to lower maintenance and longer life.

5. Lifespan

• Clay tiles can last 75–100 years with proper care.

• Concrete tiles often last 40–75 years.

The decision depends on how long you plan to stay in your home—and how much you're willing to invest now vs later.

So... Which Should You Choose?

If you’re after timeless beauty, low maintenance, and top-tier longevity—clay is hard to beat.

If you want a great look, solid durability, and lower upfront cost—concrete is a strong contender.

At The Roof Champion of Columbus, we don’t just give you a catalog and walk away. Travis walks you through real samples, color swatches, and past projects to help you choose with clarity.

We’ve helped homeowners across Powell, Upper Arlington, and Westerville choose the right tile—based on your goals, budget, and home style.

FAQ: Clay vs Concrete Roof Tiles

How long does each tile type last?
Clay can last over 75 years. Concrete typically lasts 40–75 years.

Do concrete tiles fade faster than clay?
Yes. Concrete tiles are often surface-colored and can fade with UV exposure. Clay retains color better over time.

Can my home handle the weight of tile?
That depends on your roof’s structure. We inspect that during your free consultation.

Are both tiles energy efficient?
Yes. Both offer excellent insulation due to the air space under the tiles, which helps reduce heat transfer and lower energy costs.

Want to see samples and compare side by side?
Call Travis at (614) 639-3422 or book online.

We make tile roofing simple—and beautiful.