How to Get Perfect Shingle Color Matching for Your Roof Replacement in Columbus, Ohio
Shingle Color Matching: How to Avoid a Patchy Roof Replacement
You’ve probably seen it—homes with roof patches that stick out like a sore thumb. Whether it’s from storm damage repairs or a partial roof replacement, mismatched shingles can ruin your curb appeal and even lower property value.
If you’re planning a roof replacement or repair in Columbus, Powell, or Dublin, here’s how to get shingle color matching done the right way.
Why Shingle Color Matching Matters
Protects Home Value
Enhances Curb Appeal
Prevents HOA Violations (Yes, some neighborhoods care!)
Gives You Peace of Mind Knowing the Job Looks Complete
Here’s How We Get It Right at The Roof Champion
1. We Start with the Manufacturer’s Exact Product Line
Every shingle manufacturer—whether it’s Owens Corning, Malarkey, or IKO—has specific color names and blends. If we installed your roof or know the previous installer, we’ll pull exact product specs to match perfectly.
🛠️ Real Example:
Last month in Hilliard, we replaced a storm-damaged section of a roof using Owens Corning’s “Driftwood” color. Because we had access to the original shingle data, the repair blended seamlessly—no one could tell the difference.
2. Checking Weathering and Aging
Shingles fade over time due to sunlight, weather, and algae. Even if we find the exact color, the new shingles might still look off next to older, faded ones.
Here’s what we do:
Compare color samples in direct sunlight on your roof.
If the color difference is too noticeable, we may recommend replacing a larger area to avoid obvious patches.
Sometimes, it’s simply not in your best interest to do a small repair that looks bad. Travis says it best:
"If I wouldn’t accept it on my own home, I won’t recommend it for yours."
3. Special Orders and Custom Solutions
For older roofs, some colors have been discontinued. In these cases, we:
Search supplier warehouses for remaining inventory.
Recommend blending similar colors in a pattern that makes the transition look intentional.
This method works especially well for complex rooflines and shaded areas where color differences are less noticeable.
4. Insurance Claim? We’ll Fight for Full Replacement
When storm damage affects a noticeable portion of your roof and exact color matching isn’t possible, insurance should cover full replacement under the "matching" clause.
And trust us—we fight hard for that outcome.
🛠️ Real Example:
Lisa in Gahanna faced this exact issue. Her insurance company wanted to patch her hail-damaged roof with whatever was “close enough.” We documented the mismatch, negotiated with her insurer, and got her a full roof replacement—all with perfectly matching new shingles.
Ready to Get It Done Right?
If your roof has damage or you’re considering an update, don’t settle for a mismatched repair. Call The Roof Champion of Columbus, and we’ll make sure your roof looks as good as new—because that’s exactly what you deserve.
📞 Call Now: (614) 639-3422
📍 Visit Us: 177 Chasely Circle, Powell, Ohio 43065
🌐 Learn More: www.roofchampcolumbus.com
